Scotts seeing like a state, i was studying at a farleft canadian university, and in one of its furthestleft graduate programs. Imagine a wellmeaning but terminally stupid new admin assistant taking a look. The central premise of seeing like a state james c. Seeing like a state summarizes the sort of ontheground ultraempirical knowledge that citizens have of city design and peasants of farming as metis, a greek term meaning practical wisdom. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading seeing like a state. If you want to read the argument of seeing like a state in his own words, he wrote a short version of the whole book for the cato institute. Compulsory ujamaa villages in tanzania, collectivization in russia, le corbusiers urban planning theory realized in brasilia, the great leap forward in china, agricultural modernization in the tropics. Scott critical of a system of beliefs he calls high modernism, that centers around confidence in the ability to design and operate society in accordance with scientific laws.
Scott describes how states seek to make the social world legible and how the quest for legibility leads to costly and. In seeing like a state, and as a student of politics, i concentrate on statemaking and government. The state expansion, by threatening the moral economy of peasants, could trigger rebellion and a fight against the expansion of the state. Seeing like a state why nations fail why nations fail. Scott analyzes failed cases of largescale authoritarian plans in a variety of fields. Scotts fascinating and seminal book, seeing like a state. Seeinq like a state by michael adas rutgers university seeing like a state. Jul 26, 2010 a big little idea called legibility july 26, 2010 by venkatesh rao james c.
I was a little concerned about this because they seem like two different things. He offers a forceful critique of political methods that seek to make legible societies, cultures, and practices that developed without. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed seeing like a state. Lal james scott is an anthropologist and political scientist. Seeing like a state was arranged kind of like the premodern forests and villages it describes. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed the institution for social and policy st kindle edition by scott, james c download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Seeing like the state, like scott s other work, is widely admired by many libertarians and classical liberals see here, and here. Scott starts with the story of scientific forestry in 18th century prussia. At its core, this is a book about the many failures of mankinds attempts to assert order and legibility to nature, society, and the economy. But i got a bit of grief from one reader, who thought that i had given scott far too easy a ride.
Not inherently a bad thing enables economies of scale and low friction exchanges. Scotts masterpiece on how governments develop an organizational view of reality, seeing like a state, and gareth morgans magisterial work on the role of metaphor in organization theory. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed. This view of early modern statecraft is not particularly original. Overall, seeing like a state pairs well with some of nassim nicholas talebs ideas about antifragility, skin in the game, and the precautionary principle in relation to fattail events black swans. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed is a. Legibility the state cant control or tax you if it cant see you, so it tends to want to force the world to conform to some simple model that is easy to measure and manipulate. All of these he argues persuasively shared a common goal of enhancing what he terms the legibility of urban and rural landscapes and human populations. In a transparent ruleoflaw society the control systems enabled by these are generally to the public benefit, which is why they get instituted in the first place.
Michael schrage, across the board its global focus. Seeing like a state why nations fail why nations fail by. He offers a forceful critique of political methods that seek to make legible societies, cultures, and practices that developed without strict geometrical and hierarchical order. Scott points out at an early stage in seeing like a state that the state is the vexed institution that is the source of both our freedoms and our unfreedoms something like that, at least, i dont have the book at hand.
Feb 23, 2017 scotts seeing like a state is one of my favorite social science texts. It is a passionately written essay with full of interesting facts and deep observations on dizzying diversity of topics ranging from 19th century german forestry to compulsory villagization in tanzania. It lacked anything like a detailed map of its terrain and its people. He rightly identifies these failures as the result of what f. He believes that the process of statebuilding, leading to what he calls the legibility and standardization of society, fosters control and domination. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers. In each case, officials took exceptionally complex, illegible, and local social. State projects of legibility and simplification 9 chapter 1. This process of flattening, or of making local practice legible, is not without costs. Compulsory ujamaa villages in tanzania, collectivization in russia, le corbusiers urban planning theory realized in brasilia, the great leap forward in china, agricultural modernization in the tropicsthe twentieth century has been racked by grand utopian schemes that have inadvertently brought death and. It refers to a states attempt to make society legible, to arrange the population in ways that simplified the classic state. Scott points out at an early stage in seeing like a state that the state is the vexed institution that is the source of both.
I can provide an ebook version of seeing like a state. It does not require a very thorough examination of the history of the long. In seeing like a state, and as a student of politics, i concentrate on state making and government. Scott is the eugene meyer professor of political science and anthropology at yale university and current president of the association of asian studies. The difference, and it is a crucial one, lies in the wholly new scale of ambition and intervention entertained by high modernism. This has an extraordinary number of implications for modern life, but i would like to discuss the application to charity in particular. In seeing like a state, scott makes several main arguments. Scott begins with a history of the tension between the desire for legibility versus the desire for local control.
Where local practices persist, they are typically relevant to a. Mar 05, 2009 the three things i connected were david allens subtle definition of organization. Meaning, neatness and organization getting things done. This book seems to propose itself as a changeinducing idea, but its closest sibling is burkes conservatism. Scott, 1999 is that the larger an organization is, the less it can tolerate variation between parts of itself. These state projects of legibility overlay, and often supersede, local practices. Seeing like a state the new york times web archive. Although i havent read the full book, ive read an essay by the author to get a further grasp on this concept. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed james c.
James scotts book, seeing like a state, is a study of the twentieth century practice of imposition of structure upon diverse social elements. He identifies the central problem of statecraft and of government as one of legibility. James scott is an anthropologist and political scientist. The premodern state was, in many crucial respects, partially blind. Jul 10, 2014 the state expansion, by threatening the moral economy of peasants, could trigger rebellion and a fight against the expansion of the state.
In it, he showed how central governments attempt to force legibility on their subjects, and fail to see complex, valuable forms of local social order and knowledge. The whole insistence upon the idea of resistance has always, to me looked like a misguided ideology. Perhaps the most general is that states by their nature want to make everything legible in order to control society. Much of the first chapter is intended to convey how thoroughly society and the environment have been refashioned by state maps of legibility. Seeing like seeing like a state seeing like seeing like a state crooked timber. In sum, the legibility of a society provides the capacity for largescale social engineering, highmodernist ideology provides the desire, the authoritarian state. Since he didnt, james scott had to write it a century later. In seeing like a state, scott develops the central theme of legibility, which will be involved in most of our lines of analysis below. In seeing like a state, james scott explains why certain statecentered schemes to improve the human condition have failed. Scotts brilliant and important work, seeing like a state.
Scott the institution for social and policy studies yale isps series yale agrarian studies. Seeing like a state is a worldly, academic synthesis of the destructive hubris of largescale rational planning. Scotts 1999 book seeing like a state has had an enduring influence across the ideological spectrum, and particularly in an unexpected corner among market liberals. Scotts seeing like a state shows how centralized schemes to remake society or nature with modern, streamlined, efficient plans become awful failures, and why this might be. Standardizing on common vocabulary across realm of management. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed, by james c. Those of you who know me can go to my place and send.
The book catalogues schemes which states impose upon populaces that are convenient for the state since they make societies legible, but are. In this book, james scott sets out to understand the logic behind what he calls state simplifications. Jesse walker, reason this is a book rich in ideas and arguments. Yale agrarian studies the yale isps series includes bibliographical references and index. In seeing like a state, scott develops the central theme of legibility. Inspire a love of reading with prime book box for kids.
Intervention in society or nature for whatever purpose e. A contrived example of individual humans seeing like a state. Scott describes how states seek to make the social world legible and how the quest for legibility leads to costly and often disastrous interventions. Some thoughts on seeing like a state mark koyama medium. For a state to exercise its power across a large population, it must simplify, codify, and and regularize local practices. What scott does that is brilliant is talk about how states and large institutions acquire the knowledge that they ultimately use to govern. A big little idea called legibility july 26, 2010 by venkatesh rao james c. Seeing like a state was recommended to me by yale cold war historian john gaddis. Scott, however, is a refined, disciplined scholar and writes clear, powerful prose to communicate his keen, synthetic insights. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed, james c. It was released in march 1998, with a paperback version in. Having begun to think in these terms, i began to see legibility as a central problem in statecraft. Seeing like a state february 8, 1999 edition open library.
Scotts seeing like a state is one of my favorite social science texts. I, like many of my instructors and peers, assumed that the proper goal of scholarly. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed veritas paperbacks this title will be released on march 17, 2020. In seeing like a state, scott explores how attempts to radically transform and improve the human condition have failed. The trouble with the view from above id like to come in nudge opinion in favor of james c. His seeing like a state is largely about the failure of planning in modernist cities such as chandigarh in india and brasilia in brazil, and of collectivized agriculture, particularly in the soviet union and tanzania. Or at least more legible to the allseeing statist eye in the sky many of the pictures in the book are literally aerial views than to the local, embedded, eye on the ground. Chesterton would have written if he had gone into economic history instead of literature. Legibility, after all, is a prerequisite of appropriation as well as of authoritarian transformation. Scott, february 8, 1999, yale university press edition, paperback in english new ed edition. Seeing like a state how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed.
Scott yale university press, 1998 445 pages when i first read james c. Seeing like a state how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed the institution for social and policy st new ed edition by james c. How certain schemes to imp rove the human condition have failed, examines how, across dozens of domains, ranging from agriculture and forestry, to urban planning and censustaking, a very predictable failure. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed 1998 saw his first major foray into political science. Seeing like a state remains a tremendous achievement, easily one of the most impressive and important books of recent years. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed is a book by james c. A commenter on amazons page for seeing like a state remarks on the resemblance between this legibility and burkes prejudice. In it, he showed how central governments attempt to force legibility on their subjects, and fail to see complex, valuable forms of. Those of you who know me can go to my place and send me an email or you can email richard i trust who he trusts with the alias and password necessary. Scotts book has been such a generative work, even if theres a lot that could be quibbled withnamely, the way states use illegibility and uncertainty just as productively, the no less important political effects of failure. How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed the institution for social and policy studies at yale university. James c scott in this wideranging and original book, james c.
607 717 1045 23 599 301 630 786 1186 869 981 824 717 205 721 263 1438 1085 526 19 963 975 224 442 1220 442 1112 1260 1136 989 758 991 1085 1203 411 190 897 499 936 1470 255 576 301 1051 728 529 591